Don’t tell me eBooks have no soul


** This post is dedicated to my dear friend and sister in storycraft, Kim Koning

In the little corner of the online writing and reading community that I occupy, I often come across photos, memes, slogans and posts extolling the virtues of the printed book over the eBook. I usually avoid the discussion because my appreciation for eBooks comes from living in countries where English is not the national language and no-one wants to hear me rave about my travels. However, something happened to me yesterday which made me think about the element of the print vs eBook argument which gets under my skin: the suggestion that eBooks “have no soul.”

Now, if the claim of no soul is in terms of decorating a house,  I can understand that – my favourite wall decoration is a tall bookshelf filled with the higgledy piggledy colours of print books –  but the anti-eBook people (including members of most of the mainstream book review sites and shows I tune into) are claiming that reading an eBook is a lesser experience than reading a print book, and I call shenanigans.

Words, phrases, sentences and, most of all (in my opinion) the story make up the soul of a book and these things do not change with the method of delivery. This was highlighted to me yesterday and I challenge you not to see the “soul” in the following πŸ™‚

A couple of weeks ago, I was struck down by something from which I am still recovering. I have been napping a lot, and unable to focus enough to hold my whole novel in my head in the way that I need to when in editing mode – playing Farmville and Candy Crush has been about my intellectual capacity, and I’ve been avoiding email.

Yesterday, I woke from a nap and felt the pang of guilt of having not checked my email properly for a week, so I burrowed in, pulled my tablet pc under the covers, and braved the inbox. I soon began to regret bringing the outside world  into my little haven of warmth and healing, when an email popped up from Amazon with the subject “a gift for you from Kim Koning.” The email had a short message from Kim and a link to a kindle version of The Night Circus, by Erin Morgenstern.


Those of you who join #storycraft chat each month will know Kim as my co-host of the writing tweet chat that I started in 2010 – we met when she joined as a participant on the very first chat – and she has become one of my dearest friends. Kim lives in Auckland, so our friendship takes place via approx. weekly Skype chats, and texts and conversations via Facebook in between, so she knew I’d been ill and had noticed that I had “gone dark” as she calls it when one needs to shut out  the online world for a while. The last time we had Skyped, we had discussed The Night Circus as one of her favourite books, and I’d told Kim I hadn’t read it, but that I would put it at the top of my to read list.

I tapped the prompt on the email, tapped a couple of times on the Amazon site, then shut down my computer and, without emerging from my covers, slid it onto the bedside table and whipped my Kindle in under the covers. It took barely a count of five for the book to download and then – even though I was too ill to venture even to the mailbox, even though my very dear friend was in another country – I was snuggled up, resting as I needed to, sharing her favourite book, and feeling loved because my dear friend knew I needed cheering up and sent it to me – instantly, right when I needed it. Don’t tell me there’s no soul in that. πŸ™‚

Thank you, Kimmy. Love you heaps!  xoxoxo



One comment on “Don’t tell me eBooks have no soul”
  1. says:

    Darcy,As you say the writing has that brings life and soul to a work,not the medium it is presented through.
    That would be like saying only Oil Paintings have soul and Watercolor is just for babies.
    Again it is the work not the medium presenting it.
    With Love for the novel and artist.
    Herb Collins


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s